A few months ago I had jury duty. I sat in a courtroom with 100 potential jurors as a young man sat behind a table with his attorney and we were interviewed.
They were picky because the charge was murder and the penalty would be steep.
That young man had one trial to determine whether he did or didn’t kill someone. What if the evidence brought against him was mistakenly from someone else’s trial? Imagine if an innocent man was locked up because a prosecutor brought forth a bloody knife used for a different crime. That man would be deemed a murderer due to evidence that wasn’t evidence at all.
Now, that (hopefully) doesn’t happen in America’s courtrooms. But it often happens in America’s churches. People put God on trial and claim He doesn’t exist by holding Him to promises He never made.
Typically, the teen girls who write to me with doubts about God can point to a reason why: the divorce of their parents, abuse, the death of a loved one, etc…
“If God was good, if He was real, He wouldn’t allow that to happen to me,” they write in frustration. Their hurts are real. And in many cases, their anger is valid. But their argument that if God were real, life would be pain free isn’t a well-founded one.
This is why knowing what you are looking for is important. What these girls are saying is that they are looking for a god who takes away pain and only passes out blessings. Great! Wouldn’t we all love a god like that?
The problem is, the God of the Bible never promised to make life perfect. In fact, Jesus Himself said, “In this world you will have trouble…” (John 16:33).
So, you can’t use pain to prove God doesn’t exist since He never promised to remove pain from our lives. If you are looking for a god who makes life all sunshine and roses, you aren’t looking for the God of the Bible.
If you want to know whether the God of the Bible exists, then you have to look at what He promises to do. He sets the standard you can measure Him against.
What does the God of the Bible promise us?
- His plans are to prosper you and not to harm you, to give you a future and a hope (Jeremiah 29:11)
- He works all things together for good for those who love Him and are called according to His purposes (Romans 8:28)
- Nothing can separate you from the love of God (Romans 8:38-39)
Can you look back over your life and see any good? Did you survive a dramatic attack that should have killed you? Do you have at least one parent who still loves you after a divorce? Is there a part of you crying out to God even though something awful happened? Is there still a desire to believe if His existence can be proven?
Those are good things. Glimmers of hope in the midst of tragedy. Small proofs that God is Who He says He is.
Have your bad experiences led you anywhere good? Maybe your parents got divorced, but now your alcoholic dad can no longer beat you or your mom when he is drunk. You are in a place of brokenness, but you are in a place of safety.
If you are going to call the God of the universe into question, and force Him to stand trial over whether or not He exists, you need to make sure the evidence you hold against Him is accurate. You cannot base His existence on whether or not He gives you everything you want. The only thing you can hold Him to is whether or not He provides you with everything He has promised.
Know Who you are looking for.